Why Mecha is Boring.

·

Mecha, Gundam, Gunpla, whatever they’re calling it this week, is a thing. It is a popular genre and seems to be gaining more and more popularity.

But the models are boring.

Why is this? Well, to a traditional modeller, a large, brightly-coloured Mecha that looks like a toy you would give to a 5 year old, doesn’t really count as a model. And to some extent, this holds true.

Most mecha models are snap fit, they do not require glue. They do have parts which need to be removed from the sprue, but there is basically no clean-up required. You can put the whole thing together in under an hour. Strike one!

Most mecha models come pre-coloured, with all the individual parts already finished in the requisite colours. No painting required. Strike two!

All mecha is not real, and a lot of it looks a bit silly. Strike three, Yyyyooooouuu’re out!

It is a shame. Fundamentally mecha is still modelling, but it sits on the very fringe. Traditional modellers look down their nose at it, or ignore it altogether. But really, we want the mecha crowd in our fraternity. The more the merrier. Fans of mecha buy kits, which help manufacturers like BANDAI keep on going. Fans of mecha (not the builders themselves) come to model shows and exhibitions to see mecha. They pay the entrance fee, and support the wider modelling community by handing over their cash. They buy model kits too.

It is difficult for the poor mech. They sit there at model exhibitions, invariably right next door to the fantasy figures, and in comparison, they look like toys. It’s a tough gig. So is there anything that can be done to improve the image and acceptance of mecha amongst traditional modellers?

Yes, there is. Maybe the mecha crowd don’t care what anyone else thinks. Gundam is a sub-culture and the fans are fans of the subjects, not model building itself. If so that’s cool, don’t worry about what I’m about to suggest. But if you are into mecha, and you would like to get a bit more attention, to be taken more seriously by traditional modellers, then you need to mix things up a bit. Put aside your devotion to the sub-culture and try some “modelling”. Have a go at some alternative schemes. Eschew that bright yellow and white cartoon drawing on the box, and have a go at painting a military camouflage. Don’t want to mess with the colour scheme, have a go at some serious weathering. Image your mech is a survivor of numerous battles. Paint and damage that thing up so it looks like it got into a scrap with half a dozen Abrams tanks. You will need to let go of the “lore” and try something different. Build a model, not a mech.

These things will make your mechs interesting to traditional modellers. They may have no idea about the sub-culture, but a visually interesting  mech will get their attention.

Have a go mech guys/gals/they-thems. We want you in our team.

tim

Comments

8 responses to “Why Mecha is Boring.”

  1. Panzerwomble

    S.T.A.L.K.E.R gallery is on Scaleymates FYI

  2. Guest 000007 (Gaz)

    I never got it… I have even judged it at a hobby show. But yeah… nahh.

    1. G’Day Gaz,

      I still don’t either. I really did make an effort to have a go at it, after all it is an increasingly popular category in our hobby, but it just didn’t take. I’ve dome a fair bit of Maschinen Kreiger stuff too and it, on the other hand, has grown on me. They are both from the Japanese manga-verse, but somehow feel very different.

      CHEERS
      tim

  3. HockeySock3

    Mecha …..it’s like Citrus IPA …..or Strawberry Fruit Lager …it might be ‘beer’ but…. not as I know it ….and entirely invented for a market that isn’t a 600 year old cave troll like me .

    I’ve seen a few Mechas done in a realistic style, they do look much better and give creativity a free reign ; but I just don’t understand the Manga verse it all comes from .

    That said just did a STALKER dio , and I don’t play games either 😳

    So anyway I’ll womble off ……having added really ‘zero’ to this learned article .

    Live long and Prosper !

    Hockey3

    1. G’Day HockeySock,

      You make a really good point – Mecha is directed entirely at a narrow market and seems to not appeal to anyone who is just slightly to the side of that market. Hell, it seems even Sci-Fi modellers aren’t into it. It is a very specific crowd. As you can see I have tried to jazz it up a bit with my weathering techniques, and it has worked, but even then it is still boring. I find myself thinking “Why am I doing this? If I’m going to invest the effort in the Sci-Fi realm I should do an X-wing instead.”

      Ooooooo, a STALKER dio sounds really good (links?). I really do like the sounds of that!

      Say a G’day to Socky5 and panzerwomble for me.

      CHEERS
      tim

      1. I find your sad robots series much fun, & the creativity to take one format and change it into another is most appealing .

        Never done space stuff, maybe ought to throw in the this year’s mix , although 99% of everything I build is “product” in the end and the market is fickle, so if it doesn’t sell …..

      2. I find your sad robots series much fun, & the creativity to take one format and change it into another is most appealing .

        Never done space stuff, maybe ought to throw in the this year’s mix , although 99% of everything I build is “product” in the end and the market is fickle, so if it doesn’t sell …..

        1. Thanks mate. It is nice to hear that you appreciate the Sad Robot series. Indeed it is about taking a format and making it into something else.

          Don’t be shy, have a go at some space stuff. The nice thing about Sci-Fi is that none of it is real, so you can safely do whatever you want with it.

          It’d be nice to be able to sell stuff!

          tim

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *